Startups beware: Juggling board members may drop the ball

Relating to startups, having a various and skilled board of administrators generally is a key issue to success.

As we head into this new yr, the overall consensus within the VC world is that funding can be more durable to return by and instances can be leaner when it comes to operating a enterprise. Having a robust board with an enormous title on it’s more likely to come in useful each when it comes to experience and optics.

However what occurs when a type of board members can also be a member of a dozen others?

Overboarding, because the apply of accumulating board memberships is thought, has been on many minds just lately, notably with publicly listed firms, that are taking a stance towards it. In response to PwC’s 2022 Annual Company Administrators survey, almost half of respondents acknowledged that an impartial director should not maintain greater than three board seats.

Loading up on directorships is not uncommon within the enterprise world. Round 15% of VC buyers who’ve board seats maintain greater than 4, in accordance with PitchBook information. Examples embody Khosla Ventures co-founder Samir Kaul, who holds 19 board positions in accordance with his LinkedIn profile, and Index Ventures accomplice Mike Volpi, who’s on 16 boards.
 

This text appeared as a part of The Weekend Pitch e-newsletter. Subscribe to the newsletter here.

Companies that make investments a big quantity, notably those that lead offers, will need to have extra management over the route of a startup—in any case, they’ve an obligation of care over their buyers’ cash. A board seat offers that in addition to providing a startup a stage of experience from exterior the group.

And there are execs to having a board member with a number of different board commitments. They’ve possible gained beneficial insights and information from their varied roles, and will have a rolodex filled with connections that would profit the startup.

Additional, an enormous title can present a vote of confidence for future buyers and in addition enhance an organization’s attractiveness to world-class expertise.

However as a substitute of proactively attempting to develop the startup, somebody on a dozen or 20 boards might find yourself disengaging from lack of focus or simply merely not having sufficient time. This might not be the top of the world when the nice instances are rolling, however when disaster hits and each hand is required to steer the ship, a distracted or overcommitted board can harm an organization’s efficiency.

A key a part of VC funding is the value-add from skilled and savvy buyers, but when overcommitted board members aren’t in a position to dedicate the required time, they might not be capable to successfully leverage their expertise so as to add that worth. By spreading themselves too skinny, they might miss crimson flags with doubtlessly disastrous outcomes. For examples of what can occur when boards do not pay shut consideration to rising issues at startups, see Theranos, Uber or WeWork.

Overboarding just isn’t solely damaging to startups. It is unhealthy for the board members themselves. Let’s not neglect that having this function will be exhausting, rising the chance of burnout. In fact, some corporations can have devoted portfolio groups that may do the legwork for board members when it comes to gathering the required info on an organization. However nonetheless, with a mountain of startups to assist govern on prime of different duties as an investor, the difficulties in staying knowledgeable and uncovering every startup’s wants are apparent.

There’s additionally proof {that a} excessive variety of board seats for startups is not all the time a constructive. A research from Correlation Ventures analyzing exits within the US from 1998 to 2017 discovered that startups with 4 or extra VCs on the board underperformed even when managed for funding phases, business teams and time durations. Firms with out a board carried out the worst although, so it is not for use as an excuse to eliminate exterior governance altogether.

So what’s the proper variety of board seats for an investor to carry? Properly, that relies upon.

Whether or not you are on the board of an early-stage or late-stage firm will think about. The bigger and extra established the startup grows, the much less possible you may be wanted to offer help. If the startup is performing nicely and does not have to pivot or restructure, then, once more, a board member’s providers will not be wanted as a lot.

However the instances forward will take a look at many firms. Already final yr, waves of layoffs ripped by means of the tech sector and startups centered on nothing however progress unexpectedly needed to change not solely their practices however their mentalities too. Having a member of the board with expertise and experience—and the time to deploy it—is a large assist when navigating trickier instances.

So when contemplating the composition of a board, some ideas for startups: Deal with a board seat like every other job. Giving out a seat is not a present or a reward however ought to be approached in the identical manner as hiring for any senior place. Decide individuals who have the talents and the sources to serve your organization and be express in what you anticipate from them.

Getting an enormous title on the board is nice on the subject of future funding, but when that is the one purpose they’ve the place, then it is a missed alternative to herald somebody who could possibly be extra helpful and extra engaged in the way forward for your enterprise. And do not hesitate to interchange them if attainable once they fall in need of what’s required.