Scottish government rejects Sunak’s offer to cooperate on revised gender bill – UK politics live | Politics

Final evening the federal government backed down, within the face of a possible revolt by Tory MPs that would have led to a defeat on the web security invoice, and agreed amend the laws in order that social media executives who persistently fail to guard kids may very well be jailed. My colleague Dan Milmo has the story right here.

This morning Lucy Powell, the shadow tradition secretary, stated the climbdown was an indication of weak spot. She additionally claimed the concession didn’t go far sufficient. She stated:

Labour has been calling for stronger prison sanctions for months, nevertheless the enforcement is now over a narrower set of measures after the federal government gutted a lot of the invoice earlier than Christmas.

We’ve bought no thought the place the federal government actually stand on these points. They’ve flip flopped, one minute large weakening the invoice, the following minute pressured right into a minor strengthening.

Rishi Sunak is simply too weak to face up towards vested curiosity, Labour is on the facet of the general public.

Common real-terms pay in Britain fell at among the many quickest charges for greater than 20 years on the finish of 2022, as public sector pay offers proceed to fall behind the personal sector throughout the price of dwelling disaster, newest figures from the ONS present. My colleague Richard Partington has the story right here.

Scotland’s gender recognition reform invoice has triggered a constitutional row as a result of well being (and gender recognition) are devolved issues, however equality regulation is a matter for the UK parliament.

In her At this time interview Shona Robison, the Scottish authorities’s social justice secretary, insisted that the gender recognition reform invoice wouldn’t undermine or change UK equality regulation. That is an argument the Scottish authorities has been making for a while, and Robison stated this morning.

[The bill] simplifies the method for acquiring a gender recognition certificates. It doesn’t change the impact of getting one. All the protections underneath the equality laws stay precisely the identical.

And she or he confused {that a} clause has been included within the invoice making precisely this level.

The UK authorities has not given detailed causes but as to why it has determined that the Scottish authorities is incorrect on this level. In his assertion final evening Alister Jack, the Scottish secretary, simply stated he was involved the invoice would have “an hostile influence on the operation of Nice Britain-wide equalities laws”.

However final week Coverage Change, a Tory thinktank with appreciable affect over authorities considering, printed a report saying the UK authorities ought to block the Scottish invoice. It defined by referring to a current courtroom determination. The report, written by Michael Foran, a regulation lecturer at Glasgow College, says:

The regulation regulating authorized intercourse change is discovered within the Gender Recognition Act 2004, an Act of Parliament that applies throughout the UK and which addresses each reserved and devolved issues. It supplies that to alter one’s authorized intercourse, one should first be identified with gender dysphoria and endure a two-year interval of medically supervised social transition. The Scottish Gender Recognition Reform Invoice may change all this for these born or resident in Scotland. If enacted, the Invoice would take away the requirement to be identified with gender dysphoria, scale back the statutory ready time from two years to 3 months, and decrease the minimal age for a authorized intercourse change to sixteen.

Whether or not or not this has any impact on the operation of the Equality Act – hostile or in any other case – relies on whether or not a change in “authorized intercourse” modifications one’s “intercourse” for the needs of the Equality Act. For a time, the reply to this authorized query was not clear and arguments may very well be – and had been – superior on either side. However on 13 December 2022, Woman Haldane determined the For Ladies Scotland v The Scottish Ministers (FWS2) case within the Outer Home of the Court docket of Session. Her Ladyship’s determination was {that a} Gender Recognition Certificates, issued underneath the 2004 Act, does alter one’s intercourse for the needs of the Equality Act, together with for provisions regarding the development of variety through constructive measures.

The Coverage Change paper argues that this ruling can have “profound implications”, together with “making it probably harder for women-only areas to exclude organic males”.

Requested about this argument in her At this time interview, Robison insisted that, though the invoice would change the foundations about acquiring a gender recognition certificates, it could not change the impact of getting such a certificates.

Requested if it could be more durable to limit female-only areas to folks born as biologically feminine, she replied:

The protections underneath the equality laws have exemptions. So [in] a female-only house, trans girls, whether or not or not they’ve a gender recognition certificates, will be excluded from that female-only house. That’s the present place. It remans the place. This invoice modifications none of that.

Practice drivers are to stage contemporary strikes after the rejection of a pay supply, PA Media studies. PA says:

Members of Aslef will stroll out on February 1 and three, inflicting extra journey disruption throughout the nation.

The primary strike will coincide with a walkout by 100,000 civil servants of their dispute over pay and jobs, a strike by lecturers over pay and nationwide protests towards the federal government’s controversial new strike regulation.

Mick Whelan, Aslef common secretary, stated: “The supply is just not acceptable however we’re keen to have interaction in additional discussions with the prepare working corporations.”

The businesses affected embody Avanti West Coast; Chiltern Railways; CrossCountry; East Midlands Railway; Nice Western Railway; Better Anglia; GTR Nice Northern Thameslink; London North Jap Railway; Northern Trains; Southeastern; Southern/Gatwick Specific; South Western Railway (depot drivers solely); SWR Island Line; TransPennine Specific; and West Midlands Trains.

In his assertion final evening Alister Jack, the Scottish secretary, stated the UK authorities was blocking the Scottish gender recognition reform invoice as a result of it may need an hostile influence on UK equality laws. However he stated the UK goverment can be keen to work with the Scottish authorities to make sure a revised Scottish invoice didn’t current this drawback. He stated:

If the Scottish authorities chooses to carry an amended invoice again for reconsideration within the Scottish parliament, I hope we will work collectively to discover a constructive approach ahead that each respects devolution and the operation of UK Parliament laws.

In an interview with the At this time programme this morning Shona Robison, who as social justice secretary within the Scottish authorities took the invoice by way of the Scottish parliament rejected this supply.

The Scottish authorities doesn’t settle for that the invoice does influence on UK equality laws – it even features a clause particularly saying it has no influence on the Equality Act – and Robison stated she didn’t assume Jack’s supply was honest.

She stated that, if the UK authorities genuinely believed that it had authorized grounds to problem the invoice due to its influence on UK equality regulation, it could have used a section 33 order as a substitute of a bit 35 one. Part 33 of the Scotland Act permits the UK or Scottish authorities to refer a invoice to the supreme courtroom for a ruling on whether or not or not it’s authorized underneath the devolution settlement that reserves some issues to Westminster. This has occurred previously (not like using a bit 35 order).

Robison went on:

Utilizing the part 35 nuclear choice, I believe, reveals that they don’t have a authorized foundation to problem it, and that is extra in regards to the politics than it’s in regards to the laws.

And I don’t assume the UK authorities are going to return ahead with a options of a tweak right here or a tweak there. They’re essentially towards this invoice. They don’t like this invoice.

And they’re utilizing their energy to cease the democratically elected Scottish parliament taking ahead laws that had the overwhelming help fo that parliament.

The Scottish authorities is as a substitute anticipated to go to courtroom itself to problem the legality of the UK authorities’s 35 order. That dispute would find yourself within the supreme courtroom.

Good morning. Alister Jack, the Scottish secretary, is without doubt one of the least recognized and most powerless members of the cupboard. The Scottish authorities largely decides how public companies are delivered in Scotland, and the place the UK authorities is in total cost, it’s typically one other cupboard minister, not Jack. However in the present day he finds himself on the centre of an unprecedented row between Westminster and Holyrood, as a result of he’s the minister who has to subject the part 35 order that the UK authorities is utilizing to dam the Scottish authorities’s gender recognition reform invoice. It’s the first time a section 35 order has been issued since devolution began nearly 1 / 4 of a century in the past.

Jack issued a statement about this final evening, however he’s anticipated to face questions from MPs when he delivers a press release to the Commons later. Right here is our in a single day story.

Gillian Keegan, the schooling secretary, was doing the morning interview spherical in the present day. One of many objections to the Scottish invoice is that it’s going to enable folks to begin the method of adjusting gender from the age of 16 and, when requested if she thought this was too younger on Sky Information, she didn’t agree. She replied:

No, I don’t really [think 16 is too young]. I used to be working at 16, I used to be paying tax at 16, I used to be making choices for myself at 16.

This made her sound extra liberal on this than Keir Starmer, who yesterday stated he thought 16 was too young.

However, by the point she appeared on ITV’s Good Morning Britain, maybe realising that her preliminary reply put her at odds together with her Tory colleagues, she stated that for some folks, 16 is perhaps too younger. Requested about her reply earlier on Sky, she stated:

I stated ‘Look, you understand, at 16, I used to be working, I used to be paying tax’, however all 16-year-olds are totally different.

Clearly, all people has a distinct view. It’s actually, actually necessary that we take note of mother and father’ views, lecturers’ views, kids’s views, and different stakeholders’ views as nicely as a result of it’s fairly difficult.

However what I stated was, you understand, for me, myself, I felt in a position to take choices for myself at 16. However… I’d grown up fairly shortly and I used to be really working full-time at 16.

Keegan additionally stated that the federal government was proper to intervene, and that the part 35 course of was included within the Scotland Act exactly for circumstances like this. She stated:

The secretary of state for Scotland has used this energy as a result of we will’t have two competing gender and equality legislations.

So we have to have a look at that and must work out what to do, and he’ll be setting out and making a press release in a while in the present day in parliament.

Right here is the agenda for the day.

Morning: Rishi Sunak chairs cupboard.

11.30am: Grant Shapps, the enterprise secretary, takes questions within the Commons.

11.30am: Downing Avenue holds its foyer briefing.

12pm: Penny Mordaunt, the chief of the Commons, speaks at an Institute for Authorities convention. Stephen Flynn, the SNP chief at Westminster, and Lisa Nandy, the shadow levelling up secretary, are additionally talking.

After 12.30pm: Alister Jack, the Scottish secretary, is anticipated to make a press release to MPs in regards to the authorities’s determination to dam Scotland’s gender recognition reform invoice.

Afternoon: MPs debate the remaining levels of the web security invoice. Ministers will verify that, in response to a potential revolt by Tory MPs, they’ll settle for an modification that would see social media executives going through jail in the event that they persistently fail to guard kids.

I’ll attempt to monitor the feedback beneath the road (BTL) however it’s not possible to learn all of them. When you have a direct query, do embody “Andrew” in it someplace and I’m extra more likely to discover it. I do attempt to reply questions, and if they’re of common curiosity I’ll submit the query and reply above the road (ATL), though I can’t promise to do that for everybody.

If you wish to entice my consideration shortly, it’s in all probability higher to make use of Twitter. I’m on @AndrewSparrow.

Alternatively, you may electronic mail me at andrew.sparrow@theguardian.com